| Year | Pro Winner | Farm Winner |
|---|---|---|
| 36 | Kings |  Brass |
| 34 | Rangers | Brass |
| 33 | Golden Seals |  Tigers |
| 32 | Barons |  Growlers |
| 29 | Bruins | Nailers |
| 10 | Maroons |  Bombers |
| 9 | Bruins |  Bears |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 8 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 5 | Rangers | Reds |
| 4 | Rangers | Bombers |
| 3 | Bruins | Nighthawks |
| 2 | ||
| 2 | ||
| 1 | Bruins | Reds |
Mooseheads
Thunder
Tigers
Americans
Fighting Saints
Ice Flyers
Wings